It sounds like BioWizard might be very useful for the purpose you describe, but I think it would work much better for you if you could create a community of reviewers of articles (members of The Family Physicians Inquiries Network) so that members could limit the aggregate rating of any particular article to those ratings and comments that were offered by other members of your community.

I’d also like to see RSS integration. Imagine that you could assign journals or articles to particular reviewers, and that they would receive links to abstracts automatically via RSS or email (as one can at Medworm.com). Imagine how convenient it would be for those recipients to click on a link sent via RSS or email in order to go to BioWizard (or a similar tool) and start entering their ratings and comments.

Also, it would be great if members of your community could “tag” articles. For instance, they might tag an article as “Policy:FPIN” to make an article they think should be considered when reviewing or riviising policy. This would require, though, that BioWizard make tags or comments searchable.

Again, I think BioWizard is a great start, but there’s so much more that could be done with this idea to maximize its usefulness for your purposes.

Best,

-David