davidrothman.net

davidrothman.net

Exploring Medical Librarianship and Web Geekery

 
 
 
 

Physician Rating Sites: Pew-pew-pew!

Bleah. Yet another article about Web sites for rating doctors.

Is anyone else really tired of seeing these articles and pretending these sites matter? They might one day, but they don’t now.

pew-pew-pew-small Anyway, the Pew Internet and American Life Project (Please tell me I’m not the only one who quietly thinks “pew-pew-pew!” to himself every time Pew is mentioned?) says:

Nearly half (47%) of internet users, or 35% of adults, have turned to the internet for information about doctors or other health professionals.”

Nothing surprising there.

“These health information seekers, however, are not likely to post their own reviews of doctors: just 7% of those who looked for information about doctors online (and 4% of all internet users) report posting a review of a doctor online.”

Well, nothing surprising there, either. The vast majority of Wikipedia’s users (or Digg’s) are there to read, not to contribute. Isn’t this the overwhelming trend in most “social media”? (And wouldn’t noting this context be important? What does this item from Pew mean without such context?)

I’ll state again that I think every physician rating site I’ve seen is useless. When patrons (or friends) ask me how to find a good specialist, I recommend avoiding these sites. The advice I gave one family member was to get in touch with local, regional, and national patient support groups for the diagnosed (or suspected) condition necessitating a visit to a specialist. If you want the opinion of informed patients, that’s where you’ll find it.

Just for good measure:

I like lolcats. Sue me.

Like this post? Subscribe to the RSS feed!

5 Responses to “Physician Rating Sites: Pew-pew-pew!”

  1. 1
    Bart:

    Bleah. Yet another article about Web sites for rating doctors. Is anyone else really tired of seeing these articles and pretending these sites matter? They might one day, but they don’t now. Anyway, the Pew Internet and American Life Project (Please tell me I’m not the only one who quietly thinks “pew-pew-pew!” to [...]

  2. 2
    Bart:

    Bleah. Yet another article about Web sites for rating doctors. Is anyone else really tired of seeing these articles and pretending these sites matter? They might one day, but they don’t now. Anyway, the Pew Internet and American Life Project (Please tell me I’m not the only one who quietly thinks “pew-pew-pew!” to [...]

  3. 3
    Sarah:

    Since you like lolcats, I thought I’d pass this along:

    http://leavesamark.wordpress.com/2009/08/19/lolpharma/

  4. 4
    David Rothman:

    Sarah, that’s GREAT! Thanks!

  5. 5
    davidrothman.net » LOLpharm (Friday Fun):

    [...] via: http://leavesamark.wordpress.com/2009/08/19/lolpharma/ (Thanks to Sarah for pointing this out.) [...]

Pages

Get our Book!


Advertisement




Recent Comments

Archives

RSS Incoming Links

  • Numérique, e-books & co (07/03/10) March 7, 2010
    > eBooks, Audiobooks, Overdrive and DRM (source: davidrothman.net, 03/03/2010) > Publishers speak up about eBooks – Aptara Survey Results... […]
  • Ebooks, audiobooks, overdrive and drm March 5, 2010
    What else should I add to this list? What are the books that no medlib geek should be without? (Source: davidrothman.net) […]
  • 50 Health & Medical Search Engines Worth Using March 2, 2010
    ...davidrothman.net: Includes a search engine aimed at helping consumers navigate health and medical information. […]
  • Web 3.0 February 23, 2010
    It is not surprising that web 3.0 would be met with controversy, and even [http://davidrothman.net/2008/01/08/dis... […]
  • Heart to heart giveaway February 22, 2010
    I've been trying to wait until bloglines* can get itself together and work properly again to post this, but I have other stuff I am dying to show you already! The final two heart to heart swappers very generously sent along an extra ... […]
  • Add Medical Terms to Spell Checker in Word February 22, 2010
    David Rothman has an informative post about adding medical terms to your spell checker in Word. Rather than adding medical terms individually, you can populate your spell checker with thousands of medical terms from one file, ... […]
  • The Placebo Effect Explained in a video February 21, 2010
    Thanks to David Rothman. This is why placebo controlled trials are extremely necessary and seldom done. […]
  • Duly noted February 20, 2010
    Following my posting on best practices, David Rothman, Community's blogging librarian, chided me this week with a copy of "Parachute use to prevent death and major trauma related to gravitational challenge: systematic review of ... […]
  • Bij het stoppen van Biomedbiblog January 11, 2010
    Via Ronald zag ik dat Biomedbiblog stopt: daar moest ik wel even van slikken. Ik begrijp het wel, maar het is evengoed erg jammer dat het niet gelukt is om voldoende draagvlak te krijgen om het te continueren. ... […]
  • Top 50 Blogs to Learn About Health Administration December 28, 2009
    ...lating to legal issues that affect physicians and non-institutional providers. eHealth and Health IT Chilmark Research : This blog provides perspectives on key IT trends in the healthcare sector. davidrothman.net : David is the Information Services Specialist at the Community General Hospital Medical Library, but he also provides great ideas for 2.0 tools […]

Subscribe

Posts (RSS)
Comments (RSS)

Enter your email address to receive email updates of new posts:



Search

 


Contact



card.ly

Elsewhere Online

Reciprocal Blogroll